Underwhelming

The City of Iowa City, under the headline “City of Iowa City issues statement on Sept. 25 incident” in reference to the highly visible chasing, tackling and detention, by unidentified agents of the state, presumably from United States Immigration and Customs Enforcement, using an unmarked van, of Jorge Elieser González Ochoa during his work day in downtown Iowa City:

The City of Iowa City is aware of an incident involving federal law enforcement at Bread Garden Market, 225 S. Linn St., that occurred around 11 a.m. on Thursday, Sept. 25, 2025. The City was not involved in the initial incident and did not have advanced knowledge.

As the incident was unfolding, Iowa City Police were dispatched to Bread Garden for a disturbance in progress related to the incident. The federal law enforcement action was concluded prior to officers’ arrival.

Because the City had no prior knowledge and was not directly involved with this incident, all questions should be directed to federal authorities.

Since this “not us” statement: nothing.

There were local politicians, some of whom are running for reelection, who provided some proof-of-attending-the-call-to-action social media posts.

There’s nothing on the agenda for the regular work session or the regular formal meeting on Tuesday.

Meanwhile, we have well-meaning white people ready to call 911 if ICE shows up [buzzer noise and/or sad trombone] and understandably scared or at least uncomfortable folks who wonder what the fuck local government might do if something like this happens again.

So what the fuck are you doing?

Wrong, Period

Nate Holdren in The Little Village:

People of conscience must not let ourselves be pulled into line-drawing between acceptable and unacceptable instances of this violence committed by the government. The historical record is very clear that justice movements lose when they let themselves be sidetracked into litigating when forms of state violence are acceptable vs. unacceptable, often in an effort to seem reasonable so as to be palatable to the rich, powerful, and officially respectable.

This letter is about ICE and immigration and deportation but also slavery and war and civil rights and capital punishment and torture and other forms of state violence.

Don’t stop there. It’s also about why people of conscience must work to end policing full stop.

The Narrative

Des Moines Public Schools Superintendent Ian Roberts was reportedly well loved by the community, students, parents and teachers. He’s well educated and a former Olympian. Here he is in a suit racing students for fun. It’s sweet.

So the Ministry of Truth got to work.

Sam Olson, described by the Associated Press as an “ICE enforcement and removal operations regional official”:

This suspect was arrested in possession of a loaded weapon in a vehicle provided by Des Moines Public Schools after fleeing federal law enforcement.

[…]

How this illegal alien was hired without work authorization, a final order of removal, and a prior weapons charge is beyond comprehension and should alarm the parents of that school district.

Iowa Gov. Kim Reynolds in a press release:

The arrest on Friday of Des Moines Public Schools Superintendent Ian Roberts was shocking, particularly his attempt to evade authorities, and the loaded gun, knife, and large sum of cash found in his vehicle.

Rep. Ashley Hinson, who is running for US Senate, on her campaign X account:

ICE arrested the Superintendent of Des Moines Public Schools, Ian Andre Roberts — an illegal alien from Guyana & active ICE fugitive with a deportation order since May 2024. When ICE caught him, agents found a loaded gun, a hunting knife, and $3,000 in cash.

Rep. Randy Feenstra on his campaign X account:

Thank you to ICE for detaining the Superintendent of Des Moines Public Schools — an illegal immigrant with a criminal record who was caught with a loaded gun and $3,000 in cash.

All of these people are rabid supporters of a broad interpretation of the Second Amendment, but in their mind Black people aren’t afforded that right. Now, throw in the mention of a “hunting” knife (Roberts was reportedly a hunter and it is nearly hunting season in Iowa) and cash — the only source for which is the ICE official’s statement — and you’ve got yourself A Narrative™ straight from the Scary Black Man Who Deserves Whatever He Gets Playbook.

The prolific use of the phrase “illegal alien” and the random inclusion of a Scary Black Man photo from 2020 are red flags this trope is in play, of course. Journalists should be skeptical, and the public shouldn’t fall for the framing.

The rule of law includes the presumption of innocence and due process.

Abduction & Terrorism & Law Enforcement

A few thoughts about the local impact of the abduction, by federal agents, of Jorge Elieser González Ochoa from his place of work in downtown Iowa City:

The time, place and manner of the seizure is the point. As the organization Escucha Mi Voz said, “This reckless action is an attack not only on Jorge and his family, but on our entire community.” This is terrorism, and the only thing that should truly be surprising is that this is the first time this has happened in Iowa City.

Bystanders calling 911 to report an abduction in broad daylight seems reasonable, but what would have happened should the Iowa City Police have arrived before Immigration and Customs Enforcement had left the scene? Almost certainly not a dearresting. More likely local law enforcement would have kept bystanders at bay.

The Little Village headline, “ICE violently seizes an immigrant worker at Bread Garden Market in Iowa City,” is accurate, but is not out of the normal range of violence expected for local law enforcement, including the Iowa City Police or Johnson County Sheriff’s departments.

So what’s next? There will be increased pressure to collaborate with ICE locally, including the State requiring us to have contracts with federal authorities for our officers, jail cells and weapons. Local officials who refuse to question our continuing and increasing investment in police and policing and then stand by “horrified” or offering other platitudes of support are failing as they become a bike fall meme.

Iowa State Employee Fired Under Freedom of Expression Policy for Expressing Negative Feelings About Charlie Kirk After His Murder

Vanessa Miller in The Gazette:

In a Sept. 23 termination letter, provided to The Gazette in response to an open records request, ISU President Wendy Wintersteeen accused Spencer of violating the Board of Regents’ “freedom of expression” policy.

Issued by Iowa State University’s Ministry of Truth.

Who Needs Data?

Cami Koons in Iowa Capital Dispatch:

The U.S. Department of Agriculture has canceled a report that hunger-fighting organizations say was “essential” data to see the results of federal and local policies aimed at ending hunger. 

USDA, in a news release about the decision said the reports were “redundant, costly, politicized” and did “nothing more than fear monger.”

You can’t fix what you don’t measure.

University of Iowa Drops Out of Top 100 in New U.S. News National College Rankings

Pete Matthes, UI senior adviser to the president and vice president for external relations, as quoted by The Gazette‘s Vanessa Miller:

At the University of Iowa, we had record applications and the second-largest class in our history […] In other words, parents and students have voted with their feet.

[…]

As for the list-makers — too often they are substituting an algorithm for what families measure: access, achievement, and careers.

These lists are just made up, but they aren’t meaningless and falling out of this reflects poorly on the University of Iowa, which has seen a variety of declines, and probably compounds these problem.

Chatter Around the Flag

My state representative, Elinor Levin, on her official Facebook account:

There’s a lot of chatter around Johnson County Board of Supervisors Chair Jon Green’s decision not to fly the flag at half staff in honor of Charlie Kirk.

I abhor violence to my very core. It sickens me. I am a child who lost a parent young (not to violence, thankfully), and every time a person dies of unnatural causes, every time someone threatens another person, every time someone is at risk- I don’t think about the victim or potential victim- I think about those who will be left behind. It is never the person who dies who is left heartbroken- it is those who love them.

So, I have thought a lot about it in the past three days, and I respect Chair Green’s decision. Charlie Kirk SHOULD NOT have been shot. It was wrong, and left so many people across the country in grief.

But, we CANNOT let the honor of a flag at half-staff be used as a political plaything. We cannot lower it for every person who dies due to gun violence in the USA; there are not enough days in the year. Chair Green did not call for Charlie Kirk’s death- he would never do such a thing. He did not celebrate Charlie Kirk’s death- he would never do such a thing.

He recognized that Charlie Kirk was a man who, through the exercise of his right to free speech, hurt many, many people. Kirk spoke against the right to exist freely, to self-determination, for so many of the people I know and love. He invited people to “prove [him] wrong” without any demonstrated interest in changing his mind. He uplifted division and disenfranchisement.

Those he left behind have my deepest condolences and love. He does not get my respect.

Pretty pitch perfect.

‘Joint Authority’ for Johnson Co., Iowa City Law Enforcement Facility Would Have Legal Power

Ryan Hansen for the Press-Citizen:

Iowa City and Johnson County leaders held their first public meeting to discuss a joint law enforcement facility, though city leaders stopped short of committing to the project.

The full panel of Iowa City City Councilors and Johnson County Supervisors heard presentations from local design firm Shive-Hattery and the Johnson County Attorney’s Office during a 90-minute meeting on Wednesday, Sept. 10.

[…]

Johnson County formally asked Iowa City to consider a joint facility on Aug. 28. The Iowa City City Council is expected to formally consider the county’s inquiry at its next meeting on Sept. 16.

If the city is interested, the county likely will ask them to consider forming a “joint authority” by Oct. 1. A joint authority is required by Iowa law to operate a combined facility.

Human Decency and Politics

Iowa Gov. Kim Reynolds on Facebook, criticizing Jon Green, current chair of the Johnson County Board of Supervisors, for deciding the Johnson County would not lower its flags in honor of Charlie Kirk.

It’s disgraceful that a locally-elected official has chosen to put politics above human decency during a time like this.

Instant a politician criticizes another politician for being political you can ignore the rest of their argument.

The truth is that “politics” and “human decency” do not align well unless your politics are “human decency” which often, unfortunately, isn’t very popular in practice (see: NIMBYism). Of course accusing a politician of putting politics above human decency is hypocritical and in bad faith.


Update: Ironically, Supervisor Green is reportedly getting death threats. The “human decency” Gov. Reynolds says she wants, includes, at least in my mind, not threatening to kill locally elected officials who decide to…[checks notes]…fly the American flag at full-staff. I look forward to her condemnation of these threats.