Headline from CNN, Nov. 14, 2026: “After 26 Years, the US Has Lost Its Measles Elimination Status”
Headline in The Verge, two years ago, on Oct. 29, 2024: “A Vote for Donald Trump is a Vote for School Shootings and Measles”
Headline from CNN, Nov. 14, 2026: “After 26 Years, the US Has Lost Its Measles Elimination Status”
Headline in The Verge, two years ago, on Oct. 29, 2024: “A Vote for Donald Trump is a Vote for School Shootings and Measles”
Four defeats should tell county leaders something beyond the difficulty of reaching a 60% supermajority. They have not convinced enough voters that their proposals are the right solutions at an acceptable cost.
The county needs to understand why. A University of Iowa survey conducted last year suggested substantial public support for the concept of a new jail and sheriff’s office. Yet when voters were asked to approve a specific $94.5 million bond issue, just 46% supported it. That disconnect deserves serious examination.
Supervisors should commission an independent post-election survey to determine what drove voters’ decisions and what changes might make a future proposal acceptable. Was it the price, the size of the facility, concerns about incarceration policies or something else? The county should find out rather than speculate.
At the end of the day, this is a political problem to solve.
The previous jail justice center proposals, in 2012 and 2013, received 56% and 54% approval respectively. The campaign then acknowledged racial disparities, the need for diversion, and didn’t rely on a simplistic “it’s time” message (it did rely on the same, unfixed old building problems, however). It offered transparency into the decision making, and identified key programs that more space would offer.
This time around, voters were presented The Solution, leaders failed to acknowledge any tradeoffs, and the public was told we’ve done what we can for diversion. There was an unwillingness to talk about what programs might be possible with more space, or to provide data on current ones.
What changed that Supervisor Jon Green went from calling the proposal “the Taj Majail” to being a supporter? We don’t really know. When I asked, he wrote “I was wrong. A facility that meets the needs of the county is going to look significantly different than what it’s replacing,” but that’s not really an explanation.
Further, trying to argue this was about saving money, when the proposed interest payments dwarfed the expense of out-of-county incarceration, which has trended down, significantly, from its peak, and taxpayers were going to see an increase in property taxes to pay for, was a poor messaging choice.
Sheriff Brad Kunkel is a very likable person, and he stumped for the bond better than anyone, but if the county wants to get something done, they need someone from outside law enforcement who can be the face of this. And it can’t be a paid consultant who would benefit from its passage.
Further, waiting more than a decade to put something in front of voters while to saying its urgent strains credibility.
My cynical take is leaders saw the 75% support in the study they commissioned and figured they had it in the bag, even if they lost another 10 to 14 percentage points of “yes” voters. But that number had no connection to reality: cost, size, and location weren’t stated.
I campaigned against the bond, and even I said doing nothing isn’t an option. (We actually haven’t done nothing: the county invested several million into the building, unaccounted for in the Shive-Hattery report’s “do nothing” scenario.)
The answer cannot be just another survey. It’s a fine piece of data to collect, but this was a transparency and echo chamber problem. I mean, was Kunkel actually surprised it was defeated, as Trish Mahaffey reported?
Meanwhile, the County Attorney’s office has long since moved out of the court house into leased offices. Surely at least some members of the Sheriff’s Department could, too, especially since we’re told “the need to be at our physical Sheriff’s Office is getting less and less as time goes by.” So why does it have to be under one roof?
What changed between the 2013 plan, which was an expansion on site, and today, when we’ve been told it has to be this new property on the edge of town? And why won’t the University of Iowa, which has a police department who uses the jail, not contribute some real property to the cause since it won’t pay a penny more in property taxes (it pays zero)?
As the county looks ahead, it would do well to avoid stepping on the same rake. While there is pressure to come up with an answer for what’s next, moving forward without stopping to listen and build real community involvement can only result in fresh paint on the original plan.
Reconstituting the Criminal Justice Coordinating Committee, even with a slightly different makeup or name, will have the same problems.
Doing something substantially different will take more than the nine months the county has to put together a new ballot measure.
Leaders should show some patience and figure out how to do this differently instead of just rolling into The Next Thing.
Soumya Karlamangla for The New York Times:
Over the past three years, a rotation of recently released inmates, many of them convicted of murder, has cycled through the home of Surmiche Vaughn, 42, and her husband, Scott Patterson, 47. The houseguests are part of a program run by an Oakland nonprofit trying to keep former prisoners off the street.
Overall, 24 men have stayed with the couple, usually five or so at a time.
[…]
Having a safe place to land and the care of people who don’t treat them as criminals can be transformative, [Berkley sociologist Reuben Jonathan Miller] said.
There were lots of snarky suggestions during the campaign that folks opposing the jail should volunteer to house folks who would otherwise be incarcerated. There are, of course, people willing to do this, even in more extreme cases (these folks get paid $1,500 person).
Ezra Klein as a guest on the Search Engine podcast (stick with me):
You have this metaphor in American politics, it comes from George W. Bush, where he says after his reelection, “I’ve earned political capital, and I intend to spend it.”
He does spend it. He tries to privatize social security. And it makes him hideously unpopular and in part leads to the 2006 midterm.
But I’ve been thinking about that line lately, because actually what rich people do with capital is not spend it. They invest it, right?
That’s the point of capital. You invest it thoughtfully, and then you get all this extra capital, right? It begins to build for you. And the question for Democrats right now is not how to spend the power they got. It’s how to invest the power they got.
I’ve been talking to friends this week, just like normal, people who follow the news who are stunned by the size of what just happened, whose immediate thought is kind of like: how are the Democrats going to fuck this up?
It would be Democrats if listen to themselves and not to the voters.
Klein is talking about national politics and big, blue, libbed-out, capital-D Democrats. But I’ve been thinking about this in the context of local politics and, more specifically, the defeat (again) of the jail bond.
This coalition earned political capital. This coalition of immigrants, trans folks, community organizers and activists, and, yes, abolitionists, earned political capital.
While it is tempting, after a campaign that included a lot of angry, racist, transphobic, dismissive, dehumanizing, spiteful attacks online, to pull out the flame thrower1, that would just spend that capital, and not even in a politically expedient way.
It would be buying junk food with the endowment.
So how do we invest it, and not just spend it?
The answer, I think, includes making sure we’re bringing an even greater diversity to the table, and that we’re listening to — and being led by — that diversity of voices in an equitable way.
Through the campaign, county leaders pointed at the Criminal Justice Coordinating Committee as the group with diverse backgrounds in the criminal punishment system, convened to provide input on the jail. But folks I talked to who served on the committee, but weren’t front-and-center in the advocacy campaign, said it became obvious to them early on the CJCC was convened as a cheerleading squad to whom county leaders could point as the group with diverse backgrounds in the criminal punishment system convened to provide input on the jail.
We justly poked holes in the county’s official characterization. But it’s important we don’t fall into the same easily sprung trap.
Now is where the real work begins.
The works has always required folks working inside, folks working outside, and folks working alongside systems. Of course inside is very much a place of white, cis, capital supremacy and will require thoughtful navigation.
But now is chance to invest political capital to build power by centering and sharing power with those who are most harmed by our current system, and who are vulnerable to expanded carceral power.
With a majority of voters saying “no” to the latest proposal for a new $94.5 million jail and sheriff’s office, and the Board of Supervisors and Sheriff Brad Kunkel unsure of what’s next, we should talk about what the community wants. Or at least what I want.
It’s always dangerous to try drawing a clear meaning from a yes-or-no ballot measure, but with a majority of voters rejecting the latest proposal, some introspection is warranted on the part of county leaders.
As someone who knocked doors, I know some of it was cost1, some of it was size2, some of it was location3, some of it was the connection to ICE, some of it was just the idea of a tax increase4.
There were plenty of political missteps as part of the work, too. Holding a man on an ICE detainer for five extra days in the run-up to voting, for example, and advocates refusing to grant a single criticism only played into the anti-jail narrative, while many opponents disarmed the advocates’ “but we have to” messaging by simply granting the premise that nothing wasn’t an option forever.
Kunkel and other advocates also rejected compromise throughout the process:
Some opponents argued this was just a building voters should view it in that light, but what a jail is simply cannot be ignored.5 Jails are a key part of a system that disproportionately harms Black and brown folks, trans folks, immigrants, unhoused folks, and low-income folks. And, no matter how hard we try, they are not humane.6
So what would I see that might allow me to stand down?
The start must be a wholistic plan that commits to a countywide goal of zero incarceration, which would frame next steps while also recognizing current state law and other realities make this an aspirational goal akin to other goals of zero we accept. And it must include a position, outside the County Attorney and Sheriff’s offices, to oversee county diversion and prevention programs with its own budget and oversight power.
Things I would like to see in a proposal:
None of these are wild.
Trish Mahaffey for The Gazette:
[County Sheriff Brad] Kunkel told The Gazette he doesn’t know how to come up with a better plan than the one voters rejected.
“I understand the concern over costs, but we consulted experts because jails require standards and security measures,” Kunkel said. “I think we took a conservative approach on the size of the jail and what will be needed in the future. We didn’t ask for anything we didn’t need.”
He also pointed out how much money the county has already spent on a needs assessment and design plan and a community perspective study for the proposed jail and sheriff’s office.
The needs assessment study and design work by Shive-Hattery Architecture and Engineering Consultants cost $673,854 and ended with the proposal for 120-bed jail and sheriff’s office that was on Tuesday’s ballot.
Another $53,000 went to the University of Iowa Center for Social Science Innovation for a community study that polled a sample of county residents to gauge public input on a new jail.
Lydia Gerety for The Daily Iowan:
Iowa City resident Nick Bergus explained he previously told the Board of Supervisors the jail bond would fail, and he felt that community concerns about the bond were dismissed.
“As we chart a path forward, leaders need to listen,” he said. “They need to actually hear us. They need to be transparent. We need to be honest about trade-offs. There is not one answer to this, and to present a single solution as the answer is a failure.”
North Liberty resident Daniel Mills spent time before the election door knocking to hear residents’ concerns about the proposed alternatives to a new jail. He said residents care about the conditions in the jail and the people who are being held.
“Our community does not believe there are disposable people,” [Daniel] Mills said. “The folks that are on this board also believe there are not disposable people.”
Mills said, moving forward, the board should focus on addressing policies at the jail to improve conditions for detainees.
Iowa City resident Malina Amjadi said she was excited that the bond was struck down. As the board considers future decisions, Amjadi asked them to improve current policies at the jail related to health care.
“My request is that we investigate that issue and do everything we can to make sure people currently in the jail get the care that they need,” she said.
Trish Mahaffey for The Gazette:
The excitement quickly died by 10 p.m. at the watch party at Field Day in North Liberty when the results started rolling in. The packed private room had slowly filtered out before the final results came in, but Sheriff Brad Kunkel, who was confident earlier in the night, his family and few others remained to see the $94.5 million bond referendum didn’t pass. It received just over 46% (32,232 of 69,590 votes). The bond needed 60%.
Johnson County Deserves Better, the political action committee running the No New Jail campaign in Johnson County, Iowa:
Tonight, Johnson County spoke loudly: voters soundly rejected a $94.5 million debt for more of the same, expensive public safety strategies. They made it clear we deserve better.
Johnson County rejected a big, new, expensive jail and sheriff’s office, because we want to – and we can – do so much more. Because we deserve better than this. Because we deserve to be engaged about the tradeoffs, asked for input about our priorities, and offered clear explanations of how a proposed jail fits into the community safety ecosystem we envision and that we deserve.
We came to this conversation centering truth and logic, solidarity and interconnectedness, liberation and freedom, a deep desire to imagine more than cages, and love.
Tonight was a rejection of the status quo, of the idea that the community will sign off on plans county leaders devised without us. Johnson County rejected the false choice between this proposed jail and nothing.
Now we hope county leaders will — finally — listen, and start to collaborate with the community as they should have from the very beginning.
Tomorrow, it’s vital that we set aside the acrimony from the election and look for ways to move the community forward. To talk about what community safety in Johnson County should look like. About how we can address safety systemically and holistically.
We have a year before voters might again consider a proposal. It is incumbent on county leaders — Sheriff Brad Kunkel, County Attorney Rachel Zimmermann Smith, reelected Supervisors Jon Green, Lisa Green-Douglass, V Fixmer-Oraiz, Mandi Remington, Supervisor-elect Sue Dvorsky, and even outgoing Supervisor Rod Sullivan — to have these tough conversations, and to have them with the community and without ego. We are ready to think creatively and to find solutions for hard problems.
We understand the need to plan for the long term, which is why we know we deserve a plan that includes investments in the systems and infrastructure that prevent harm — meaning fewer victims — rather than those that react to it. A long-term solution means more care, not more cages.
That’s how the Johnson County we know thinks and works. That is who we are. That is why, as we seek to responsibly provide safety and dignity for our community, Johnson County deserves better.
Corporate-owned utilities charged the average household $823 a year, compared with $494 for publicly owned systems – a difference of $329, or 67%. Corporate systems accounted for just 11% of the 500 systems the study analyzed but represented 44% of the 25 most expensive systems. The study added that 70% of the top 10 were owned by for-profit corporations.
Capitalism eats everything.